Tuesday Feb 04, 2025
136:🤘Metallica’s Thrash Era w/ Longtime Friends Billy D'Elia & Jeremy Madson
Dan welcomes back longtime friends & Nostalgia Test Podcast Allstars Billy D’Elia & Jeremy Madson to put Metallica's Thrash Era to the ultimate test—THE NOSTALGIA TEST!
“Not only is it a four album progression, but it's [Metallica's] first four albums!"
-Jeremy Madson
Get ready Nostalgia Metalheads because this is just the beginning of the Metallica journey. On this episode Dan, Billy, & Jeremy get into Metallica's first four albums, their Thrash Era albums: Kill 'Em All, Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, and ...And Justice for All. They not only talk about the Thrash era itself, they go deep into each album, talk about their favorite songs & memories, are their any bad songs on these albums, the stories and rumors behind the making of these albums, the genius of Cliff Burton, Lars (of course), is Dave Mustaine the Syd Barrett of Metallica, the connections to Pink Floyd, and so much more.
In the end, they each rank the Thrash Era albums from best to "worst."
Email us (thenostalgiatest@gmail.com) ranking so we can share them on the Black Album, Load, Reload episode!
APPROXIMATE RUN OF SHOW:
00:00 Introduction and Banter
00:38 Nostalgia Test Podcast Begins
00:54 Introducing the Guests
02:29 Discussing Metallica's Thrash Era
02:46 Metallica's Early Influences and Evolution
04:03 Comparing Metallica's Albums
13:44 Cliff Burton's Influence
15:48 Kill 'Em All: A Deep Dive
23:25 Ride the Lightning: A Quantum Leap
45:19 Debating the Lulu Era
45:50 Drummer Alternatives and Nostalgia
48:26 Master of Puppets: First Impressions
49:46 Tour Stories and Metal Influences
52:00 Battery and Thrash Scene
56:21 Master of Puppets: Song Breakdown
01:00:44 Ozzy Tour and Metallica's Rise
01:06:03 Reflecting on Metallica's Impact
01:17:27 And Justice for All: Introduction
01:24:01 Middle School Memories and Metallica
01:24:49 Debating Metallica's Greatest Songs
01:26:07 Concert Experiences and Heavy Metal
01:27:57 Discussing Metallica's Weakest Tracks
Contact/Book The Nostalgia Test Podcast!
If you had a great time listening to The Nostalgia Test Podcast and want to book us on your next podcast or have perform at your themed party, or have us host a special event, fill out the form below and LET'S GET NOSTALGIC!
We can do so many fun Nostalgic Events!
- Podcast Guest Appearances
- Themed Parties
- Hosting Screenings
- Corporate Events
- Reunions
- Weddings
- Birthday Parties
- Trivia
Email us at thenostalgiatest@gmail.com or fill out the Google Form below to get the process started. We're open to in-person and virtual events. Pricing may vary depending on the details of your event/party.

Instagram | Substack | Discord | TikTok | Bluesky | YouTube | Facebook
The intro and outro music ('Neon Attack 80s') is by Emanmusic.
The Lithology Brewing ad music ("Red, White, Black, & Blue") is by PEG and the Rejected
Comments (0)
To leave or reply to comments, please download free Podbean or
No Comments
To leave or reply to comments,
please download free Podbean App.